Housing in Fishers Island, NY

Home values, rent, ownership rates, and housing market data

Housing Market Snapshot

Source: Redfin — December 2025

Median Sale Price

$1,860,000

Median List Price

N/A

Price Per Sq Ft

$512

Days on Market

Active Inventory

N/A

Price Trends

Source: Redfin

Sale Price ↓ 81.4%Oct 24 → Dec 25

Market Competitiveness

Source: Redfin

Sold Above List

100.0%

Sale-to-List Ratio

143.6%

Seller's market

Sold Above Asking

100.0%

Market Activity

Source: Redfin

Homes Sold

Homes Sold ↑ 0.0%Oct 24 → Dec 25

Price Per Square Foot

Source: Redfin

Median Sale $/SF

$512

Sale $/SF ↓ 59.7%Oct 24 → Dec 25

Census Housing Data

Source: U.S. Census Bureau ACS (2023)

Median Home Value

N/A

Median Rent

N/A

Total Housing Units

166

Vacancy Rate

89.8%

Owner Occupied

17.6%

Renter Occupied

82.3%

Median Property Tax

N/A

per year

Monthly Cost (w/ Mortgage)

N/A

Housing Types

Single Family

94.6%

Multi-Family

4.2%

Mobile Home

1.2%

The current median sale price in Fishers Island, NY is $1,860,000 according to Redfin data. Homes spend a median of 30 days on the market. 100.0% of homes sold above asking price. The median price per square foot is $512. About 17.6% of housing units are owner-occupied. The median year homes were built is 1954. There are 166 total housing units.