Population
Scotchtown
10,544
Middle Island
11,086
Median Income
Scotchtown
$92,889
Middle Island
$89,702
Home Value
Scotchtown
$317,400
Middle Island
$347,900
Rent
Scotchtown
$1,655
Middle Island
$1,774
Crime Rate
Scotchtown
N/A
Middle Island
N/A
Cost of Living
Scotchtown
152.5
Middle Island
157.8
Avg Temp
Scotchtown
N/A
Middle Island
N/A
Unemployment
Scotchtown
7.2%
Middle Island
4.4%
How Similar Are Scotchtown & Middle Island?
Middle Island is Scotchtown's #8 most similar city
6 of 8 key metrics match within 10%
Population
Scotchtown
10,544
Middle Island
11,086
Both cities have similar populations — Scotchtown at 10,544 and Middle Island at 11,086.
Political Leaning
Scotchtown
54.2%
Middle Island
55.0%
Both cities lean Republican with similar vote shares — 1% difference.
Unemployment
Scotchtown
7.2%
Middle Island
4.4%
Scotchtown has a 39% higher unemployment than Middle Island.
Median Income
Scotchtown
$92,889
Middle Island
$89,702
Both cities have similar median income — just a 3% difference.
Home Values
Scotchtown
$317,400
Middle Island
$347,900
Both cities have similar home values — just a 9% difference.
Education
Scotchtown
21.9%
Middle Island
23.1%
Both cities have similar education — just a 5% difference.
Demographics
Scotchtown
36.6%
Middle Island
76.3%
Middle Island's demographics is significantly higher than Scotchtown's — 52% difference.
Cost of Living
Scotchtown
152.5
Middle Island
157.8
Both cities have similar cost of living — just a 3% difference.
6 out of 8 key metrics match within 10%. Scotchtown and Middle Island share several key characteristics.
At a Glance
0
Scotchtown
0
Middle Island
Cost of Living & Affordability — Scotchtown leads
Source: City Stats Index / HUDScotchtown has a fair market rent (1br) of $1,549 vs $2,379 in Middle Island (35% lower). Scotchtown has a fair market rent (2br) of $1,979 vs $2,747 in Middle Island (28% lower). Scotchtown scores 191.4 on the housing index (100 = national avg) vs 211.6 in Middle Island.
Overall Cost Index
Housing Index
Food Index
Transportation Index
Healthcare Index
Utilities Index
Living Wage (1 Adult)
Living Wage (Family of 4)
Fair Market Rent (1BR)
Fair Market Rent (2BR)
Housing Market
Source: U.S. Census Bureau ACSScotchtown has a vacancy rate of 1.2% compared to 7.6% in Middle Island. Middle Island has a owner-occupied of 66.7% compared to 48.1% in Scotchtown. Scotchtown has a median property tax of $6,508 vs $7,934 in Middle Island (18% lower).
Median Home Value
Median Rent
Median Property Tax
Owner-Occupied
Vacancy Rate
Single-Family Homes
Jobs & Economy
Source: U.S. Census Bureau ACSMiddle Island has a unemployment rate of 4.4% compared to 7.2% in Scotchtown. Scotchtown: 6,427 vs Middle Island: 5,652 for labor force. Middle Island has a private sector of 95.1% compared to 84.0% in Scotchtown.
Median Household Income
Per Capita Income
Poverty Rate
Unemployment Rate
Labor Force
Mean Commute
Work from Home
Private Sector
Government Sector
Crime & Safety
Source: FBI UCRViolent Crime Rate (per 1K)
Property Crime Rate (per 1K)
Murder Rate (per 1K)
Robbery Rate (per 1K)
Assault Rate (per 1K)
Burglary Rate (per 1K)
Larceny Rate (per 1K)
Violent Crime Clearance
Property Crime Clearance
Weather & Climate
Source: NOAA / Open-MeteoAvg Annual Temperature
Avg Annual High
Avg Annual Low
Sunny Days per Year
Annual Rainfall
Annual Snowfall
Avg Humidity
Schools & Education — Middle Island leads
Source: NCES / U.S. Census BureauMiddle Island has a high school diploma or higher of 45.2% compared to 40.0% in Scotchtown. Middle Island has a bachelor's degree or higher of 23.1% compared to 21.9% in Scotchtown.
Public Schools
Avg Student-Teacher Ratio
Colleges & Universities
Bachelor's Degree or Higher
High School Diploma or Higher
Demographics & Community
Source: U.S. Census Bureau ACSMiddle Island has a population of 11,086, about 1.1x the size of Scotchtown (10,544). Scotchtown skews younger with a median age of 36.5 vs 43.4.
Population
Median Age
Avg Household Size
Married Population
Foreign Born
White
Black
Hispanic
Asian
Scotchtown
Middle Island
Healthcare — Middle Island leads
Source: CMS Hospital CompareMiddle Island: 3.8 vs Scotchtown: 3.3 for avg cms rating (out of 5).
Nearby Hospitals
Avg CMS Rating (out of 5)
With Emergency Services
Transportation & Commute — Scotchtown leads
Source: U.S. Census Bureau ACSScotchtown has a public transit of 2.3% compared to 1.0% in Middle Island. Scotchtown has a work from home of 7.4% compared to 6.8% in Middle Island. Middle Island has a drive alone of 81.0% compared to 74.7% in Scotchtown.
Mean Commute Time
Drive Alone
Public Transit
Bicycle
Work from Home
Airports
Cities Similar to Scotchtown, NY
Compare Scotchtown against its closest statistical matches across demographics, income, crime, health, and more.
City Comparison
8-axis fingerprint: population, income, housing, crime, education, age, climate, and cost of living. Click legend items to toggle.