Population
North Tonawanda
30,338
St. Clair Shores
58,287
Median Income
North Tonawanda
$66,774
St. Clair Shores
$72,693
Home Value
North Tonawanda
$184,900
St. Clair Shores
$196,400
Rent
North Tonawanda
$914
St. Clair Shores
$1,143
Crime Rate
North Tonawanda
1.54
St. Clair Shores
1.85
Cost of Living
North Tonawanda
105.5
St. Clair Shores
112.1
Avg Temp
North Tonawanda
N/A
St. Clair Shores
N/A
Unemployment
North Tonawanda
6.0%
St. Clair Shores
4.5%
How Similar Are North Tonawanda & St. Clair Shores?
St. Clair Shores is North Tonawanda's #13 most similar city
6 of 10 key metrics match within 10%
Population
North Tonawanda
30,338
St. Clair Shores
58,287
St. Clair Shores has a 48% larger population than North Tonawanda.
Violent Crime
North Tonawanda
1.54
St. Clair Shores
1.85
St. Clair Shores has a 17% higher violent crime than North Tonawanda.
Property Crime
North Tonawanda
10.87
St. Clair Shores
10.65
Both cities have similar property crime — just a 2% difference.
Political Leaning
North Tonawanda
57.5%
St. Clair Shores
55.9%
Both cities lean Republican with similar vote shares — 3% difference.
Unemployment
North Tonawanda
6.0%
St. Clair Shores
4.5%
North Tonawanda has a 25% higher unemployment than St. Clair Shores.
Median Income
North Tonawanda
$66,774
St. Clair Shores
$72,693
Both cities have similar median income — just a 8% difference.
Home Values
North Tonawanda
$184,900
St. Clair Shores
$196,400
Both cities have similar home values — just a 6% difference.
Education
North Tonawanda
20.0%
St. Clair Shores
22.7%
St. Clair Shores has a 12% higher education than North Tonawanda.
Demographics
North Tonawanda
91.2%
St. Clair Shores
88.9%
Both cities have similar demographics — just a 2% difference.
Cost of Living
North Tonawanda
105.5
St. Clair Shores
112.1
Both cities have similar cost of living — just a 6% difference.
6 out of 10 key metrics match within 10%. North Tonawanda and St. Clair Shores share several key characteristics.
At a Glance
0
North Tonawanda
0
St. Clair Shores
St. Clair Shores leads in 4 of 8 categories
Cost of Living & Affordability — North Tonawanda leads
Source: City Stats Index / HUDNorth Tonawanda scores 102.1 on the transportation index (100 = national avg) vs 109.3 in St. Clair Shores. North Tonawanda scores 112.3 on the housing index (100 = national avg) vs 120.0 in St. Clair Shores. North Tonawanda scores 105.5 on the overall cost index (100 = national avg) vs 112.1 in St. Clair Shores.
Overall Cost Index
Housing Index
Food Index
Transportation Index
Healthcare Index
Utilities Index
Living Wage (1 Adult)
Living Wage (Family of 4)
Fair Market Rent (1BR)
Fair Market Rent (2BR)
Housing Market — St. Clair Shores leads
Source: U.S. Census Bureau ACSSt. Clair Shores has a median property tax of $2,921 vs $4,520 in North Tonawanda (55% lower). St. Clair Shores has a vacancy rate of 3.8% compared to 5.6% in North Tonawanda. St. Clair Shores has a single-family homes of 87.0% compared to 67.5% in North Tonawanda.
Median Home Value
Median Rent
Median Property Tax
Owner-Occupied
Vacancy Rate
Single-Family Homes
Jobs & Economy — St. Clair Shores leads
Source: U.S. Census Bureau ACSSt. Clair Shores has a poverty rate of 7.7% compared to 12.1% in North Tonawanda. St. Clair Shores: 31,636 vs North Tonawanda: 16,362 for labor force. St. Clair Shores has a unemployment rate of 4.5% compared to 6.0% in North Tonawanda.
Median Household Income
Per Capita Income
Poverty Rate
Unemployment Rate
Labor Force
Mean Commute
Work from Home
Private Sector
Government Sector
Crime & Safety — North Tonawanda leads
Source: FBI UCRNorth Tonawanda has a property crime clearance of 31.1% compared to 11.5% in St. Clair Shores. North Tonawanda has a burglary rate (per 1k) of 1.24 compared to 3.50 in St. Clair Shores. St. Clair Shores has a larceny rate (per 1k) of 5.60 compared to 8.46 in North Tonawanda.
Violent Crime Rate (per 1K)
Property Crime Rate (per 1K)
Murder Rate (per 1K)
Robbery Rate (per 1K)
Assault Rate (per 1K)
Burglary Rate (per 1K)
Larceny Rate (per 1K)
Violent Crime Clearance
Property Crime Clearance
Weather & Climate
Source: NOAA / Open-MeteoAvg Annual Temperature
Avg Annual High
Avg Annual Low
Sunny Days per Year
Annual Rainfall
Annual Snowfall
Avg Humidity
Schools & Education — St. Clair Shores leads
Source: NCES / U.S. Census BureauSt. Clair Shores has a bachelor's degree or higher of 22.7% compared to 20.0% in North Tonawanda.
Public Schools
Avg Student-Teacher Ratio
Colleges & Universities
Bachelor's Degree or Higher
High School Diploma or Higher
Demographics & Community
Source: U.S. Census Bureau ACSSt. Clair Shores has a population of 58,287, about 1.9x the size of North Tonawanda (30,338). North Tonawanda skews younger with a median age of 42.6 vs 43.7.
Population
Median Age
Avg Household Size
Married Population
Foreign Born
White
Black
Hispanic
Asian
North Tonawanda
St. Clair Shores
Healthcare — North Tonawanda leads
Source: CMS Hospital CompareNorth Tonawanda: 2.8 vs St. Clair Shores: 2.3 for avg cms rating (out of 5).
Nearby Hospitals
Avg CMS Rating (out of 5)
With Emergency Services
Transportation & Commute — St. Clair Shores leads
Source: U.S. Census Bureau ACSSt. Clair Shores has a public transit of 0.6% compared to 0.1% in North Tonawanda. St. Clair Shores has a bicycle of 0.3% compared to 0.1% in North Tonawanda. North Tonawanda has a work from home of 14.0% compared to 12.3% in St. Clair Shores.
Mean Commute Time
Drive Alone
Public Transit
Bicycle
Work from Home
Airports
Cities Similar to North Tonawanda, NY
Compare North Tonawanda against its closest statistical matches across demographics, income, crime, health, and more.
City Comparison
8-axis fingerprint: population, income, housing, crime, education, age, climate, and cost of living. Click legend items to toggle.