Population
Mackinac Island
663
Fire Island
445
Median Income
Mackinac Island
$100,125
Fire Island
$90,179
Home Value
Mackinac Island
$834,600
Fire Island
$608,500
Rent
Mackinac Island
$1,164
Fire Island
$1,750
Crime Rate
Mackinac Island
1.68
Fire Island
N/A
Cost of Living
Mackinac Island
179.8
Fire Island
177.6
Avg Temp
Mackinac Island
N/A
Fire Island
N/A
Unemployment
Mackinac Island
9.1%
Fire Island
0.0%
How Similar Are Mackinac Island & Fire Island?
Fire Island is Mackinac Island's #5 most similar city
4 of 8 key metrics match within 10%
Population
Mackinac Island
663
Fire Island
445
Mackinac Island has a 33% larger population than Fire Island.
Political Leaning
Mackinac Island
61.8%
Fire Island
55.0%
Both cities lean Republican, but Mackinac Island has a stronger Republican lean (11% difference).
Unemployment
Mackinac Island
9.1%
Fire Island
0.0%
Mackinac Island's unemployment is significantly higher than Fire Island's — 100% difference.
Median Income
Mackinac Island
$100,125
Fire Island
$90,179
Both cities have similar median income — just a 10% difference.
Home Values
Mackinac Island
$834,600
Fire Island
$608,500
Mackinac Island has a 27% higher home values than Fire Island.
Education
Mackinac Island
27.8%
Fire Island
27.2%
Both cities have similar education — just a 2% difference.
Demographics
Mackinac Island
56.4%
Fire Island
56.0%
Both cities have similar demographics — just a 1% difference.
Cost of Living
Mackinac Island
179.8
Fire Island
177.6
Both cities have similar cost of living — just a 1% difference.
4 out of 8 key metrics match within 10%. Mackinac Island and Fire Island share several key characteristics.
At a Glance
0
Mackinac Island
0
Fire Island
Cost of Living & Affordability — Fire Island leads
Source: City Stats Index / HUDMackinac Island has a fair market rent (1br) of $780 vs $2,379 in Fire Island (67% lower). Mackinac Island has a fair market rent (2br) of $1,023 vs $2,747 in Fire Island (63% lower). Fire Island scores 137.9 on the transportation index (100 = national avg) vs 153.1 in Mackinac Island.
Overall Cost Index
Housing Index
Food Index
Transportation Index
Healthcare Index
Utilities Index
Living Wage (1 Adult)
Living Wage (Family of 4)
Fair Market Rent (1BR)
Fair Market Rent (2BR)
Housing Market — Mackinac Island leads
Source: U.S. Census Bureau ACSFire Island has a single-family homes of 96.1% compared to 46.6% in Mackinac Island. Fire Island has a owner-occupied of 77.4% compared to 48.5% in Mackinac Island. Mackinac Island has a median home value of $834,600 vs $608,500 in Fire Island (37% higher).
Median Home Value
Median Rent
Median Property Tax
Owner-Occupied
Vacancy Rate
Single-Family Homes
Jobs & Economy
Source: U.S. Census Bureau ACSFire Island has a poverty rate of 3.2% compared to 17.3% in Mackinac Island. Mackinac Island: 462 vs Fire Island: 256 for labor force. Fire Island has a work from home of 15.6% compared to 8.2% in Mackinac Island.
Median Household Income
Per Capita Income
Poverty Rate
Unemployment Rate
Labor Force
Mean Commute
Work from Home
Private Sector
Government Sector
Crime & Safety
Source: FBI UCRViolent Crime Rate (per 1K)
Property Crime Rate (per 1K)
Murder Rate (per 1K)
Robbery Rate (per 1K)
Assault Rate (per 1K)
Burglary Rate (per 1K)
Larceny Rate (per 1K)
Violent Crime Clearance
Property Crime Clearance
Weather & Climate
Source: NOAA / Open-MeteoAvg Annual Temperature
Avg Annual High
Avg Annual Low
Sunny Days per Year
Annual Rainfall
Annual Snowfall
Avg Humidity
Schools & Education — Mackinac Island leads
Source: NCES / U.S. Census BureauMackinac Island has a high school diploma or higher of 46.8% compared to 38.9% in Fire Island. Mackinac Island has a bachelor's degree or higher of 27.8% compared to 27.2% in Fire Island.
Public Schools
Avg Student-Teacher Ratio
Colleges & Universities
Bachelor's Degree or Higher
High School Diploma or Higher
Demographics & Community
Source: U.S. Census Bureau ACSMackinac Island has a population of 663, about 1.5x the size of Fire Island (445). Mackinac Island skews younger with a median age of 39.8 vs 48.7.
Population
Median Age
Avg Household Size
Married Population
Foreign Born
White
Black
Hispanic
Asian
Mackinac Island
Fire Island
Healthcare — Fire Island leads
Source: CMS Hospital CompareFire Island: 5 vs Mackinac Island: 1 for nearby hospitals. Mackinac Island: 4.0 vs Fire Island: 2.3 for avg cms rating (out of 5). Fire Island: 3 vs Mackinac Island: 1 for with emergency services.
Nearby Hospitals
Avg CMS Rating (out of 5)
With Emergency Services
Transportation & Commute
Source: U.S. Census Bureau ACSMackinac Island has a bicycle of 23.9% compared to 5.6% in Fire Island. Fire Island has a drive alone of 54.8% compared to 4.1% in Mackinac Island. Fire Island has a work from home of 15.6% compared to 8.2% in Mackinac Island.
Mean Commute Time
Drive Alone
Public Transit
Bicycle
Work from Home
Airports
Cities Similar to Mackinac Island, MI
Compare Mackinac Island against its closest statistical matches across demographics, income, crime, health, and more.
City Comparison
8-axis fingerprint: population, income, housing, crime, education, age, climate, and cost of living. Click legend items to toggle.