Mackinac Island, MI vs Dugway, UT — Compare Cost of Living, Housing, Crime & More

Population

Mackinac Island

663

Dugway

441

Median Income

Mackinac Island

$100,125

Dugway

$104,145

Home Value

Mackinac Island

$834,600

Dugway

N/A

Rent

Mackinac Island

$1,164

Dugway

$1,053

Crime Rate

Mackinac Island

1.68

Dugway

N/A

Cost of Living

Mackinac Island

179.8

Dugway

130.1

Avg Temp

Mackinac Island

N/A

Dugway

N/A

Unemployment

Mackinac Island

9.1%

Dugway

2.7%

Loading map…

How Similar Are Mackinac Island & Dugway?

Dugway is Mackinac Island's #23 most similar city

3/7

3 of 7 key metrics match within 10%

Population

👥

Mackinac Island

663

Dugway

441

Different · 33% difference

Mackinac Island has a 33% larger population than Dugway.

Political Leaning

Mackinac Island

61.8%

Dugway

69.1%

Different · 10% difference

🗳️

Both cities lean Republican, but Dugway has a stronger Republican lean (10% difference).

Unemployment

💼

Mackinac Island

9.1%

Dugway

2.7%

Different · 70% difference

Mackinac Island's unemployment is significantly higher than Dugway's — 70% difference.

Median Income

Mackinac Island

$100,125

Dugway

$104,145

Match · 4% difference

💰

Both cities have similar median income — just a 4% difference.

Education

🎓

Mackinac Island

27.8%

Dugway

30.2%

Match · 8% difference

Both cities have similar education — just a 8% difference.

Demographics

Mackinac Island

56.4%

Dugway

61.2%

Match · 8% difference

🌍

Both cities have similar demographics — just a 8% difference.

Cost of Living

💵

Mackinac Island

179.8

Dugway

130.1

Different · 28% difference

Mackinac Island has a 28% higher cost of living than Dugway.

3 out of 7 key metrics match within 10%. Mackinac Island and Dugway differ in most key areas.

At a Glance

Mackinac Island

vsof 8

Dugway

Dugway leads in 3 of 8 categories

Cost of Living & Affordability

Tied

Housing Market

Dugway

Jobs & Economy

Dugway

Crime & Safety

Tied

Weather & Climate

Tied

Schools & Education

Tied

Healthcare

Dugway

Transportation & Commute

Tied

Cost of Living & Affordability

Source: City Stats Index / HUD

Dugway scores 110.3 on the housing index (100 = national avg) vs 251.8 in Mackinac Island. Dugway scores 130.1 on the overall cost index (100 = national avg) vs 179.8 in Mackinac Island. Dugway has a living wage (1 adult) of $57,262 vs $79,103 in Mackinac Island (38% lower).

Overall Cost Index

Mackinac Island179.8

Dugway130.1

★

Housing Index

Mackinac Island251.8

Dugway110.3

★

Food Index

Mackinac Island126.5

★

Dugway129.6

Transportation Index

Mackinac Island153.1

★

Dugway159.2

Healthcare Index

Mackinac Island121.2

★

Dugway123.7

Utilities Index

Mackinac Island146.3

Dugway119.8

★

Living Wage (1 Adult)

Mackinac Island$79,103

Dugway$57,262

★

Living Wage (Family of 4)

Mackinac Island$186,970

Dugway$135,347

★

Fair Market Rent (1BR)

Mackinac Island$780

★

Dugway$946

Fair Market Rent (2BR)

Mackinac Island$1,023

★

Dugway$1,241

Housing Market — Dugway leads

Source: U.S. Census Bureau ACS

Mackinac Island has a owner-occupied of 48.5% compared to 2.5% in Dugway. Dugway has a median property tax of N/A vs $7,589 in Mackinac Island (100% lower). Dugway has a vacancy rate of 38.3% compared to 75.5% in Mackinac Island.

Median Home Value

Mackinac Island$834,600

DugwayN/A

Median Rent

Mackinac Island$1,164

Dugway$1,053

★

Median Property Tax

Mackinac Island$7,589

DugwayN/A

★

Owner-Occupied

Mackinac Island48.5%

★

Dugway2.5%

Vacancy Rate

Mackinac Island75.5%

Dugway38.3%

★

Single-Family Homes

Mackinac Island46.6%

★

Dugway30.1%

Jobs & Economy — Dugway leads

Source: U.S. Census Bureau ACS

Dugway has a unemployment rate of 2.7% compared to 9.1% in Mackinac Island. Mackinac Island has a government sector of 56.2% compared to 22.5% in Dugway. Mackinac Island: 462 vs Dugway: 349 for labor force.

Median Household Income

Mackinac Island$100,125

Dugway$104,145

★

Per Capita Income

Mackinac Island$46,601

Dugway$47,800

★

Poverty Rate

Mackinac Island17.3%

Dugway0.0%

★

Unemployment Rate

Mackinac Island9.1%

Dugway2.7%

★

Labor Force

Mackinac Island462

★

Dugway349

Mean Commute

Mackinac IslandN/A

DugwayN/A

Work from Home

Mackinac Island8.2%

Dugway9.1%

★

Private Sector

Mackinac Island93.8%

★

Dugway81.3%

Government Sector

Mackinac Island56.2%

★

Dugway22.5%

Crime & Safety

Source: FBI UCR

Violent Crime Rate (per 1K)

Mackinac Island1.68

DugwayN/A

Property Crime Rate (per 1K)

Mackinac Island85.71

DugwayN/A

Murder Rate (per 1K)

Mackinac Island0.00

DugwayN/A

Robbery Rate (per 1K)

Mackinac Island0.00

DugwayN/A

Assault Rate (per 1K)

Mackinac Island1.68

DugwayN/A

Burglary Rate (per 1K)

Mackinac Island3.36

DugwayN/A

Larceny Rate (per 1K)

Mackinac Island82.35

DugwayN/A

Violent Crime Clearance

Mackinac Island0.0%

DugwayN/A

Property Crime Clearance

Mackinac Island9.8%

DugwayN/A

Weather & Climate

Source: NOAA / Open-Meteo

Avg Annual Temperature

Mackinac IslandN/A

DugwayN/A

Avg Annual High

Mackinac IslandN/A

DugwayN/A

Avg Annual Low

Mackinac IslandN/A

DugwayN/A

Sunny Days per Year

Mackinac IslandN/A

DugwayN/A

Annual Rainfall

Mackinac IslandN/A

DugwayN/A

Annual Snowfall

Mackinac IslandN/A

DugwayN/A

Avg Humidity

Mackinac IslandN/A

DugwayN/A

Schools & Education

Source: NCES / U.S. Census Bureau

Mackinac Island has a high school diploma or higher of 46.8% compared to 35.6% in Dugway. Dugway has a bachelor's degree or higher of 30.2% compared to 27.8% in Mackinac Island.

Public Schools

Mackinac Island0

Dugway0

Avg Student-Teacher Ratio

Mackinac IslandN/A

DugwayN/A

Colleges & Universities

Mackinac Island0

Dugway0

Bachelor's Degree or Higher

Mackinac Island27.8%

Dugway30.2%

★

High School Diploma or Higher

Mackinac Island46.8%

★

Dugway35.6%

Demographics & Community

Source: U.S. Census Bureau ACS

Mackinac Island has a population of 663, about 1.5x the size of Dugway (441). Dugway skews younger with a median age of 33.8 vs 39.8.

Population

Mackinac Island663

Dugway441

Median Age

Mackinac Island40

Dugway34

Avg Household Size

Mackinac Island2.2

Dugway2.0

Married Population

Mackinac Island22.6%

Dugway38.1%

Foreign Born

Mackinac Island13.3%

Dugway6.6%

White

Mackinac Island56.4%

Dugway61.2%

Black

Mackinac Island13.6%

Dugway2.5%

Hispanic

Mackinac Island11.9%

Dugway9.1%

Asian

Mackinac Island0.0%

Dugway22.0%

Mackinac Island

Dugway

Healthcare — Dugway leads

Source: CMS Hospital Compare

Dugway: 3 vs Mackinac Island: 1 for nearby hospitals. Dugway: 3 vs Mackinac Island: 1 for with emergency services. Mackinac Island: 4.0 vs Dugway: 3.5 for avg cms rating (out of 5).

Nearby Hospitals

Mackinac Island1

Dugway3

★

Avg CMS Rating (out of 5)

Mackinac Island4.0

★

Dugway3.5

With Emergency Services

Mackinac Island1

Dugway3

★

Transportation & Commute

Source: U.S. Census Bureau ACS

Mackinac Island has a public transit of 14.2% compared to 1.5% in Dugway. Dugway has a drive alone of 80.7% compared to 4.1% in Mackinac Island. Dugway has a work from home of 9.1% compared to 8.2% in Mackinac Island.

Mean Commute Time

Mackinac IslandN/A

DugwayN/A

Drive Alone

Mackinac Island4.1%

Dugway80.7%

★

Public Transit

Mackinac Island14.2%

★

Dugway1.5%

Bicycle

Mackinac Island23.9%

★

Dugway0.0%

Work from Home

Mackinac Island8.2%

Dugway9.1%

★

Airports

Mackinac Island0

Dugway0

Cities Similar to Mackinac Island, MI

Compare Mackinac Island against its closest statistical matches across demographics, income, crime, health, and more.

🧬

City Comparison

8-axis fingerprint: population, income, housing, crime, education, age, climate, and cost of living. Click legend items to toggle.

Explore These Cities

Mackinac Island, MI → Full City Profile Dugway, UT → Full City Profile

Compare Different Cities