Central Islip, NY vs Montclair, CA — Compare Cost of Living, Housing, Crime & More

Population

Central Islip

37,751

Montclair

37,809

Median Income

Central Islip

$110,166

Montclair

$76,338

Home Value

Central Islip

$405,000

Montclair

$549,600

Rent

Central Islip

$2,106

Montclair

$1,759

Crime Rate

Central Islip

N/A

Montclair

6.44

Cost of Living

Central Islip

180.8

Montclair

150.4

Avg Temp

Central Islip

N/A

Montclair

N/A

Unemployment

Central Islip

5.6%

Montclair

6.1%

Loading map…

How Similar Are Central Islip & Montclair?

Montclair is Central Islip's #1 most similar city

5/8

5 of 8 key metrics match within 10%

Population

👥

Central Islip

37,751

Montclair

37,809

Match · 0% difference

Both cities have similar populations — Central Islip at 37,751 and Montclair at 37,809.

Political Leaning

Central Islip

55.0%

Montclair

49.7%

Match · 10% difference

🗳️

Central Islip leans Republican while Montclair leans Democratic.

Unemployment

💼

Central Islip

5.6%

Montclair

6.1%

Match · 8% difference

Both cities have similar unemployment — just a 8% difference.

Median Income

Central Islip

$110,166

Montclair

$76,338

Different · 31% difference

💰

Central Islip has a 31% higher median income than Montclair.

Home Values

🏠

Central Islip

$405,000

Montclair

$549,600

Different · 26% difference

Montclair has a 26% higher home values than Central Islip.

Education

Central Islip

11.7%

Montclair

11.3%

Match · 3% difference

🎓

Both cities have similar education — just a 3% difference.

Demographics

🌍

Central Islip

28.4%

Montclair

27.6%

Match · 3% difference

Both cities have similar demographics — just a 3% difference.

Cost of Living

Central Islip

180.8

Montclair

150.4

Different · 17% difference

💵

Central Islip has a 17% higher cost of living than Montclair.

5 out of 8 key metrics match within 10%. Central Islip and Montclair share several key characteristics.

At a Glance

Central Islip

vsof 8

Montclair

Central Islip leads in 4 of 8 categories

Cost of Living & Affordability

Montclair

Housing Market

Montclair

Jobs & Economy

Central Islip

Crime & Safety

Tied

Weather & Climate

Tied

Schools & Education

Central Islip

Healthcare

Central Islip

Transportation & Commute

Central Islip

Cost of Living & Affordability — Montclair leads

Source: City Stats Index / HUD

Montclair has a fair market rent (1br) of $1,777 vs $2,379 in Central Islip (34% lower). Montclair has a fair market rent (2br) of $2,201 vs $2,747 in Central Islip (25% lower). Montclair scores 108.3 on the food index (100 = national avg) vs 134.2 in Central Islip.

Overall Cost Index

Central Islip180.8

Montclair150.4

★

Housing Index

Central Islip248.5

Montclair216.2

★

Food Index

Central Islip134.2

Montclair108.3

★

Transportation Index

Central Islip137.9

Montclair116.7

★

Healthcare Index

Central Islip127.4

Montclair106.7

★

Utilities Index

Central Islip150.2

Montclair128.3

★

Living Wage (1 Adult)

Central Islip$79,556

Montclair$66,193

★

Living Wage (Family of 4)

Central Islip$188,041

Montclair$156,456

★

Fair Market Rent (1BR)

Central Islip$2,379

Montclair$1,777

★

Fair Market Rent (2BR)

Central Islip$2,747

Montclair$2,201

★

Housing Market — Montclair leads

Source: U.S. Census Bureau ACS

Montclair has a median property tax of $2,782 vs $9,155 in Central Islip (229% lower). Montclair has a vacancy rate of 2.7% compared to 8.9% in Central Islip. Central Islip has a owner-occupied of 77.1% compared to 53.9% in Montclair.

Median Home Value

Central Islip$405,000

Montclair$549,600

★

Median Rent

Central Islip$2,106

Montclair$1,759

★

Median Property Tax

Central Islip$9,155

Montclair$2,782

★

Owner-Occupied

Central Islip77.1%

★

Montclair53.9%

Vacancy Rate

Central Islip8.9%

Montclair2.7%

★

Single-Family Homes

Central Islip81.2%

★

Montclair63.4%

Jobs & Economy — Central Islip leads

Source: U.S. Census Bureau ACS

Central Islip has a median household income of $110,166 vs $76,338 in Montclair (44% higher). Central Islip has a poverty rate of 9.3% compared to 16.7% in Montclair. Central Islip has a per capita income of $33,129 vs $26,889 in Montclair (23% higher).

Median Household Income

Central Islip$110,166

★

Montclair$76,338

Per Capita Income

Central Islip$33,129

★

Montclair$26,889

Poverty Rate

Central Islip9.3%

★

Montclair16.7%

Unemployment Rate

Central Islip5.6%

★

Montclair6.1%

Labor Force

Central Islip19,448

★

Montclair17,787

Mean Commute

Central Islip26 min

MontclairN/A

Work from Home

Central Islip6.6%

★

Montclair5.8%

Private Sector

Central Islip96.0%

★

Montclair94.8%

Government Sector

Central Islip45.3%

★

Montclair44.3%

Crime & Safety

Source: FBI UCR

Violent Crime Rate (per 1K)

Central IslipN/A

Montclair6.44

Property Crime Rate (per 1K)

Central IslipN/A

Montclair36.46

Murder Rate (per 1K)

Central IslipN/A

Montclair0.00

Robbery Rate (per 1K)

Central IslipN/A

Montclair1.79

Assault Rate (per 1K)

Central IslipN/A

Montclair4.28

Burglary Rate (per 1K)

Central IslipN/A

Montclair5.83

Larceny Rate (per 1K)

Central IslipN/A

Montclair22.91

Violent Crime Clearance

Central IslipN/A

Montclair58.1%

Property Crime Clearance

Central IslipN/A

Montclair18.5%

Weather & Climate

Source: NOAA / Open-Meteo

Avg Annual Temperature

Central IslipN/A

MontclairN/A

Avg Annual High

Central IslipN/A

MontclairN/A

Avg Annual Low

Central IslipN/A

MontclairN/A

Sunny Days per Year

Central IslipN/A

MontclairN/A

Annual Rainfall

Central IslipN/A

MontclairN/A

Annual Snowfall

Central IslipN/A

MontclairN/A

Avg Humidity

Central IslipN/A

MontclairN/A

Schools & Education — Central Islip leads

Source: NCES / U.S. Census Bureau

Central Islip has a high school diploma or higher of 33.2% compared to 29.5% in Montclair. Central Islip has a bachelor's degree or higher of 11.7% compared to 11.3% in Montclair.

Public Schools

Central Islip0

Montclair0

Avg Student-Teacher Ratio

Central IslipN/A

MontclairN/A

Colleges & Universities

Central Islip0

Montclair0

Bachelor's Degree or Higher

Central Islip11.7%

★

Montclair11.3%

High School Diploma or Higher

Central Islip33.2%

★

Montclair29.5%

Demographics & Community

Source: U.S. Census Bureau ACS

Montclair has a population of 37,809, about 1x the size of Central Islip (37,751).

Population

Central Islip37,751

Montclair37,809

Median Age

Central Islip34

Montclair34

Avg Household Size

Central Islip3.9

Montclair3.6

Married Population

Central Islip32.2%

Montclair36.6%

Foreign Born

Central Islip37.6%

Montclair31.0%

White

Central Islip28.4%

Montclair27.6%

Black

Central Islip19.2%

Montclair5.4%

Hispanic

Central Islip61.7%

Montclair72.4%

Asian

Central Islip1.9%

Montclair10.1%

Central Islip

Montclair

Healthcare — Central Islip leads

Source: CMS Hospital Compare

Central Islip: 3.3 vs Montclair: 2.8 for avg cms rating (out of 5).

Nearby Hospitals

Central Islip5

Montclair5

Avg CMS Rating (out of 5)

Central Islip3.3

★

Montclair2.8

With Emergency Services

Central Islip4

Montclair4

Transportation & Commute — Central Islip leads

Source: U.S. Census Bureau ACS

Central Islip has a public transit of 3.1% compared to 1.1% in Montclair. Central Islip has a bicycle of 0.9% compared to 0.5% in Montclair. Central Islip has a work from home of 6.6% compared to 5.8% in Montclair.

Mean Commute Time

Central Islip26 min

MontclairN/A

Drive Alone

Central Islip75.2%

★

Montclair74.4%

Public Transit

Central Islip3.1%

★

Montclair1.1%

Bicycle

Central Islip0.9%

★

Montclair0.5%

Work from Home

Central Islip6.6%

★

Montclair5.8%

Airports

Central Islip0

Montclair0

Cities Similar to Central Islip, NY

Compare Central Islip against its closest statistical matches across demographics, income, crime, health, and more.

🧬

City Comparison

8-axis fingerprint: population, income, housing, crime, education, age, climate, and cost of living. Click legend items to toggle.

Explore These Cities

Central Islip, NY → Full City Profile Montclair, CA → Full City Profile

Compare Different Cities